MassVoter.com← Yarmouth Select BoardYarmouth Former Select Board member
Erik Tolley
Elected townwide · 4 terms in this record
Eric Tolley
A monthly email on how they voted, starting in November.
Board years
Your Yarmouth ballot: 13 quizzes, about a minute each.
Start my ballot →Record at a glance · 2018–2019 Board
How these numbers work
- Counted from the official minutes, for 2018–2019 Board only. Committee meetings and routine votes (adjourning, approving minutes) are not counted.
- Attendance counts the meetings where the minutes list Tolley as present or absent at the start.
- Only votes the minutes record member by member are counted. Voice votes and votes given only as a count (for example 6-3 with no names) are not.
- Percentages are shown only when there are at least 10 meetings or votes to count.
- A split vote is one where at least one member voted yes and another voted no. “In the minority” means on the side with fewer votes; ties are not counted.
- “Whole board” combines every member’s record for the same term.
These numbers describe the record; they are not a grade. A no vote, an abstention or a minority vote is neither good nor bad. MassVoter never rates officials.
Attendance
At the start of 21 of 37 Select Board meetings in 2018–2019 Board.
Missed
- Apr 25, 2019 · Regular: Absent
- Apr 23, 2019 · Regular: Absent
- Mar 26, 2019 · Regular: Absent
- Nov 20, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Nov 14, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Nov 13, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Oct 30, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Oct 16, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Oct 9, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Oct 2, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Sep 27, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Sep 25, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Aug 28, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Aug 21, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Aug 7, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Jun 19, 2018 · Regular: Absent
Every meeting (37)
- May 14, 2019 · Regular: Present
- May 7, 2019 · Regular: Present
- May 4, 2019 · Special: Present
- Apr 25, 2019 · Regular: Absent
- Apr 23, 2019 · Regular: Absent
- Apr 9, 2019 · Regular: Present
- Apr 1, 2019 · Special: Present (Erik Tolley joined the meeting after it began (5:30 PM).)
- Mar 26, 2019 · Regular: Absent
- Mar 19, 2019 · Regular: Present
- Mar 5, 2019 · Regular: Present
- Feb 26, 2019 · Regular: Present
- Feb 12, 2019 · Regular: Present
- Jan 29, 2019 · Regular: Present
- Jan 15, 2019 · Regular: Present
- Jan 8, 2019 · Regular: Present
- Dec 18, 2018 · Regular: Present
- Dec 4, 2018 · Regular: Present
- Nov 20, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Nov 14, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Nov 13, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Oct 30, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Oct 16, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Oct 9, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Oct 2, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Sep 27, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Sep 25, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Sep 11, 2018 · Regular: Present
- Aug 28, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Aug 21, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Aug 7, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Jul 24, 2018 · Regular: Present
- Jul 17, 2018 · Regular: Present
- Jul 10, 2018 · Regular: Present
- Jun 26, 2018 · Regular: Present
- Jun 19, 2018 · Regular: Absent
- Jun 5, 2018 · Regular: Present
- May 22, 2018 · Regular: Present
Votes where members disagreed · 2018–2019 Board
May 14Prohibit herbicide applications on Town property by the TownMotion: To move that the Board of Selectmen prohibit herbicide applications on…Failed 2–3 · Tolley: Not recorded
May 14, 2019: Prohibit herbicide applications on Town property by the Town
To move that the Board of Selectmen prohibit herbicide applications on Town property by the Town.
The minutes give only the count (2 in favor, 3 opposed), not how each member voted.
From the minutes
“MOTION: To move that the Board of Selectmen prohibit herbicide applications on Town property by the Town. Motion by: Tracy Post Seconded by: Norm Holcomb Selectman Post noted that the Town has repeatedly asked EverSource to stop spraying pesticides on the power lines, and she and Selectman Holcomb argued that safer alternatives exist. Mr. Knapik explained that the Town uses a targeted "cut and swipe" method of application, which EverSource has rejected in favor of spraying due to the large area it must maintain. The EPA considers glysophate safe to use in accordance with manufacturer's directions. The Town tried a vinegar/soap solution on Route 28 sidewalks two years ago, but was stopped by MassDOT. Alternatives may exist, but may not be practical. For example, the alternative for invasives management would be hand removal, which would be extremely expensive. The Parks & Recreation Department recommends continued use of herbicides in minimal quantities while the Town develops a policy with strict guidelines while searching for alternatives. Selectman Post offered to amend her motion to allow the Town to identify alternatives. Discussion followed regarding recent lawsuit awards. AMENDED MOTION: To move that the Board of Selectmen prohibit herbicide applications on Town property by the Town upon the beginning of FY21. Motion by: Tracy Post Seconded by: Norm Holcomb Yea 2 Nay 3.” (Motion: Post, second: Holcomb)
May 7Find a violation on February 10, 2019 of 204…Motion: To move to find a violation on February 10, 2019 of…Failed 2–3 · Tolley: Not recorded
May 7, 2019: Find a violation on February 10, 2019 of 204 CMR 2.052, permitting an illegality on the licensed premises, violation of MGL Chapter 138, Section 12, service of alcoholic beverage beyond…
To move to find a violation on February 10, 2019 of 204 CMR 2.052, permitting an illegality on the licensed premises, violation of MGL Chapter 138, Section 12, service of alcoholic beverage beyond the hours fixed by a local licensing authority for that license; which is also a violation of Yarmouth Rules and Regulations, Section 1.04(a), (c), (d), and (e).
The minutes say the motion was "not seconded", but then record a vote on it ("By a vote of: Yea 2 Nay 3"). The minutes give only the count (2 in favor, 3 opposed), not how each member voted.
From the minutes
“MOTION: To move to find a violation on February 10, 2019 of 204 CMR 2.052, permitting an illegality on the licensed premises, violation of MGL Chapter 138, Section 12, service of alcoholic beverage beyond the hours fixed by a local licensing authority for that license; which is also a violation of Yarmouth Rules and Regulations, Section 1.04(a), (c), (d), and (e). Motion by: Tracy Post; not seconded. Deliberations continued regarding the strength of the circumstantial evidence of alcohol service after licensed hours. Officer Magnuson considered it very strong. Selectman Holcomb expressed frustration at having issued the license in the first place, due to Mr. Paguay's lack of experience and language barrier. Selectman Stone advised that the potential violations would be taken separately, and in order. By a vote of: Yea 2 Nay 3.” (Motion: Post)
Apr 23Approve the entertainment license contingent on the petitioner receiving…Motion: To move to approve the entertainment license contingent on the petitioner…Passed 3–1 · Tolley: Not recorded
April 23, 2019: Approve the entertainment license contingent on the petitioner receiving all necessary building/occupancy permits, with conditions
To move to approve the entertainment license contingent on the petitioner receiving all necessary building/occupancy permits, with conditions. The conditions are that the outdoor entertainment be limited to recorded amplified music Monday-Saturday from 10 am-9 pm and on Sunday from 12 pm-8 pm. For indoor entertainment, hours can be 7 am-1 am as long as the noise and alcohol is contained within the building.
Yes: Forest, Post, StoneNo: Holcomb
From the minutes
“MOTION: To move to approve the entertainment license contingent on the petitioner receiving all necessary building/occupancy permits, with conditions. The conditions are that the outdoor entertainment be limited to recorded amplified music Monday-Saturday from 10 am-9 pm and on Sunday from 12 pm-8 pm. For indoor entertainment, hours can be 7 am-1 am as long as the noise and alcohol is contained within the building. Motion by: Tracy Post Seconded by: Mark Forest Yea 3 Nay 1 (Norm Holcomb voted in opposition).” (Motion: Post, second: Forest)
Apr 23Approve the All-Alcohol Innholder License with conditionsMotion: To move to approve the All-Alcohol Innholder License with conditions. The…Passed 3–0 · Tolley: Not recorded
April 23, 2019: Approve the All-Alcohol Innholder License with conditions
To move to approve the All-Alcohol Innholder License with conditions. The conditions are that the outdoor alcohol service be limited to Monday-Saturday from 10 am-9 pm and on Sunday from 12 pm-8 pm. For indoor service, hours can be 7 am-1 am as long as the noise and alcohol is contained within the building.
Yes: Forest, Post, StoneAbstained: HolcombThe minutes give the count as 3-0 and name Norm Holcomb as abstaining; the abstention is not in the count.
From the minutes
“MOTION: To move to approve the All-Alcohol Innholder License with conditions. The conditions are that the outdoor alcohol service be limited to Monday-Saturday from 10 am-9 pm and on Sunday from 12 pm-8 pm. For indoor service, hours can be 7 am-1 am as long as the noise and alcohol is contained within the building. Motion by: Tracy Post Seconded by: Mark Forest Yea 3 Nay 0 (Norm Holcomb abstained).” (Motion: Post, second: Forest)
Apr 23Continue with Yarmouth Golf as a Town-run enterpriseMotion: To move to continue with Yarmouth Golf as a Town-run enterprise.Failed 2–2 · Tolley: Not recorded
April 23, 2019: Continue with Yarmouth Golf as a Town-run enterprise
To move to continue with Yarmouth Golf as a Town-run enterprise.
Yes: Holcomb, StoneNo: Forest, Post
From the minutes
“MOTION: To move to continue with Yarmouth Golf as a Town-run enterprise. Motion by: Michael Stone Seconded by: Norm Holcomb Yea 2 Nay 2 (Tracy Post and Mark Forest voted in opposition and the motion failed).” (Motion: Stone, second: Holcomb)
Mar 26Recommend Article 3, the Golf Operating BudgetMotion: To move to recommend Article 3, the Golf Operating Budget.Passed 3–0 · Tolley: Not recorded
March 26, 2019: Recommend Article 3, the Golf Operating Budget
To move to recommend Article 3, the Golf Operating Budget.
The minutes give only the count (3 in favor, 0 opposed, 1 abstaining), not how each member voted.
From the minutes
“MOTION: To move to recommend Article 3, the Golf Operating Budget. Motion by: Tracy Post Seconded by: Mike Stone Yea 3 Nay 0 Abstain 1.” (Motion: Post, second: Stone)
Mar 19Recommend the proposed new DY Regional School AgreementMotion: To move to recommend the proposed new DY Regional School Agreement.Passed 4–0 · Tolley: Yes
March 19, 2019: Recommend the proposed new DY Regional School Agreement
To move to recommend the proposed new DY Regional School Agreement.
Voted: Yes
Yes: Forest, Holcomb, Post, TolleyAbstained: StoneThe minutes give the count as 4-0 and name Michael Stone as abstaining; the abstention is not in the count.
From the minutes
“MOTION: To move to recommend the proposed new DY Regional School Agreement. Motion by: Tracy Post Seconded by: Mark Forest Yea 4 Nay 0 (Selectman Michael Stone abstained).” (Motion: Post, second: Forest)
Dec 18Accept the resignation of Paul O'Brien from the Board…Motion: To move that the Board of Selectmen accept the resignation of…Passed 4–0 · Tolley: Not recorded
December 18, 2018: Accept the resignation of Paul O'Brien from the Board of Health with thanks for his years of service to the Town
To move that the Board of Selectmen accept the resignation of Paul O'Brien from the Board of Health with thanks for his years of service to the Town.
The minutes give the count as 4 in favor and none opposed, but 3 members were present for this vote (Michael Stone, Erik Tolley and Tracy Post). Showing the count only.
From the minutes
“MOTION: To move that the Board of Selectmen accept the resignation of Paul O'Brien from the Board of Health with thanks for his years of service to the Town. Motion by: Tracy Post Seconded by: Erik Tolley Yea 4 Nay 0.” (Motion: Post, second: Tolley)
Dec 18Appoint George Slamma as an associate member to the…Motion: To move that the Board of Selectmen appoint George Slamma as…Passed 4–0 · Tolley: Not recorded
December 18, 2018: Appoint George Slamma as an associate member to the Historical Commission through July 2019
To move that the Board of Selectmen appoint George Slamma as an associate member to the Historical Commission through July 2019.
The minutes give the count as 4 in favor and none opposed, but 3 members were present for this vote (Michael Stone, Erik Tolley and Tracy Post). Showing the count only.
From the minutes
“MOTION: To move that the Board of Selectmen appoint George Slamma as an associate member to the Historical Commission through July 2019. Motion by: Erik Tolley Seconded by: Tracy Post Yea 4 Nay 0.” (Motion: Tolley, second: Post)
Dec 18Reappoint Richard Gegenwarth to the architect positon on the…Motion: To move that the Board of Selectmen reappoint Richard Gegenwarth to…Passed 4–0 · Tolley: Not recorded
December 18, 2018: Reappoint Richard Gegenwarth to the architect positon on the Old King's Highway Committee through December 2019
To move that the Board of Selectmen reappoint Richard Gegenwarth to the architect positon on the Old King's Highway Committee through December 2019.
The minutes give the count as 4 in favor and none opposed, but 3 members were present for this vote (Michael Stone, Erik Tolley and Tracy Post). Showing the count only.
From the minutes
“MOTION: To move that the Board of Selectmen reappoint Richard Gegenwarth to the architect positon on the Old King's Highway Committee through December 2019. Motion by: Tracy Post Seconded by: Erik Tolley Yea 4 Nay 0.” (Motion: Post, second: Tolley)
Votes with no disagreement (177)
From the Yarmouth Select Board’s official minutes, posted in the town’s Agenda Center and its Archive Center (2018 and 2019). We check every vote against the Select Board members present and quote the exact wording. MassVoter never grades or scores officials. Photos: Town of Yarmouth (Tracy Post, Liz Argo); The Provincetown Independent, courtesy Mark Forest (Mark Forest); Cape Cod Times (Joyce Flynn); AARP (Dorcas McGurrin)
How to read these pagesWhere the votes come from, how we check them against the official minutes, what isn't included yet, and how to report a mistake.About city pages →