MassVoter.com← West Tisbury Select Board
West Tisbury Member
Elected townwide · 6 terms in this record
Cindy Mitchell
A monthly email on how they voted, starting in November.
Your West Tisbury ballot: 13 quizzes, about a minute each.
Start my ballot →On split votes, Mitchell voted the same way as…
These numbers describe the record; they are not a grade. A no vote, an abstention or a minority vote is neither good nor bad. MassVoter never rates officials.
No recent stories found that name Cynthia Mitchell in the headline or opening.
Stories that name Cynthia Mitchell in the headline or opening, newest first, from 25 free news outlets (see the list). Headlines appear as each outlet published them; MassVoter does not write, choose or rate them. Only stories that are free to read are listed.
Disclosure: MassVoter’s founder, Michael Silvia, is the publisher of Fall River Reporter and New Bedford Guide.
At the start of 44 of 46 Select Board meetings in 2025–2026 Board.
Missed
December 10, 2025: Authorize the Chair to review any edits returned from other towns, determine whether the changes are non-substantive, sign if appropriate, and return substantive changes to the full Board
Authorize the Chair to review any edits returned from other towns, determine whether the changes are non-substantive, sign if appropriate, and return substantive changes to the full Board
Voted: Yes
Yes: Miller, MitchellNo: Manter
“Ms. Miller moved to authorize the Chair to review any edits returned from other towns, determine whether the changes are non-substantive, sign if appropriate, and return substantive changes to the full Board. Mr. Manter seconded the motion. Roll Call Vote: Ms. Miller – Aye, Mr. Manter – Nay, Ms. Mitchell – Aye. The motion passed (2-1) Treasurer Position for FY27– Proposal to Extend Agreement with Jared Aponte Ms. Rand introduced the item, stating that she a.” (Motion: Miller, second: Manter)
December 3, 2025: Appoint William “Bill” Fielder as a full-time police officer for the Town of West Tisbury at Grade 6, Step 7, with the start date to be determined at a future…
Appoint William “Bill” Fielder as a full-time police officer for the Town of West Tisbury at Grade 6, Step 7, with the start date to be determined at a future meeting after coordination with the Town Accountant and confirmation of the appropriate pay-period alignment, and
The minutes give the count (2-1) but not how each member voted.
“Ms. Miller made a motion to appoint William “Bill” Fielder as a full-time police officer for the Town of West Tisbury at Grade 6, Step 7, with the start date to be determined at a future meeting after coordination with the Town Accountant and confirmation of the appropriate pay-period alignment, and Mr. Manter seconded the motion. Roll Cal Vote: Ms. Miller — Aye, Mr. Manter — Nay, (noting explicitly that his opposition was based solely on the step placement, not on Fielder’s suitability or character), Ms. Mitchell — Aye. The motion passed (2-1). Chief Cortez expressed his appreciation, stating that the department was “really excited” to welcome Mr. Fielder. The Board offered its congratulations. Discussion of Fire Prevention Officer Position.” (Motion: Miller, second: Manter)
December 3, 2025: Approve the Town Administrator contract as amended, with an effective date of December 14th, and
Approve the Town Administrator contract as amended, with an effective date of December 14th, and
Voted: Yes
Yes: Miller, MitchellNo: Manter
“Mr. Manter made a motion to approve the Town Administrator contract as amended, with an effective date of December 14th, and Ms. Miller seconded the motion. Roll Call Vote: Ms. Miller – Aye, Mr. Manter – Nay, Ms. Mitchell – Aye. The motion passed (2–1). Correspondence Fairhaven Select Board Re: Local Aid Ms. Mitchell introduced a letter that she described as “very entertaini.” (Motion: Manter, second: Miller)
August 6, 2025: Give the Town Accountant (Chelsea Joiner) supervisory authority over the Treasurer/Collector and Assistant Treasurer/Collector, contingent upon auditor approval, and
Give the Town Accountant (Chelsea Joiner) supervisory authority over the Treasurer/Collector and Assistant Treasurer/Collector, contingent upon auditor approval, and
Voted: Yes
Yes: Miller, MitchellNo: Manter
“Mr. Manter made a motion to give the Town Accountant (Chelsea Joiner) supervisory authority over the Treasurer/Collector and Assistant Treasurer/Collector, contingent upon auditor approval, and Ms. Miller seconded the motion. Roll Call Vote: Ms. Miller – Aye, Ms. Mitchell – Aye, Mr. Manter – Nay. The motion passed (2–1). Old Business Deputy Emergency Manager Roles & Responsibilities A review of “Roles and Responsibilities” for the Emergency M.” (Motion: Manter, second: Miller)
July 9, 2025: Send a letter in support of Senate Bill 2395 and directed Ms. Rand to draft it
Send a letter in support of Senate Bill 2395 and directed Ms. Rand to draft it
Voted: Yes
Yes: Miller, MitchellAbstained: Manter
“Ms. Miller made a motion to send a letter in support of Senate Bill 2395 and directed Ms. Rand to draft it. Mr. Manter seconded the motion. Roll Call Vote: Ms. Miller – Aye, Ms. Mitchell – Aye, Mr. Manter – Abstained. The motion passed (2–0- 1). Request for Approval of 401 State Road Site Plans The Board reviewed the site plans for the 401 State Road afforda.” (Motion: Miller, second: Manter)
June 18, 2025: Approve the line-item transfer of $6,000 from the Town Administrator’s expense line 192-5700 to the legal line 151-5305, and
Approve the line-item transfer of $6,000 from the Town Administrator’s expense line 192-5700 to the legal line 151-5305, and
Voted: Yes
Yes: Miller, MitchellNo: Manter
“Ms. Miller made a motion to approve the line-item transfer of $6,000 from the Town Administrator’s expense line 192-5700 to the legal line 151-5305, and Mr. Manter seconded. Roll Call Vote: Ms. Miller – Aye, Ms. Mitchell– Aye, Mr. Manter – Nay. The motion passed (2–1). Up Island Council on Aging: Recommendation to Dissolve the Howes House Building Committee Beth Kramer introduced the item, s.” (Motion: Miller, second: Manter)
June 18, 2025: Sign the Last Chane Agreement as is, and
Sign the Last Chane Agreement as is, and
Voted: Yes
Yes: Miller, MitchellNo: Manter
“Ms. Miller made a motion to sign the Last Chane Agreement as is, and Mr. Manter seconded. Roll Call Vote: Ms. Miller – Aye, Ms. Mitchell– Aye, Mr. Manter – Nay. The motion passed (2–1). The Board authorized Ms. Mitchell to sign it. Correspondence MA DEP Landfill PFAS Notice Ms. Rand reported receiving a MassD.” (Motion: Miller, second: Manter)
June 11, 2025: Appoint Bryn Schaffner as Fire Prevention Officer at Grade 8, Step 2, effective July 1, 2025, and
Appoint Bryn Schaffner as Fire Prevention Officer at Grade 8, Step 2, effective July 1, 2025, and
Voted: No
Yes: Manter, MillerNo: Mitchell
“Mr. Manter made a motion to appoint Bryn Schaffner as Fire Prevention Officer at Grade 8, Step 2, effective July 1, 2025, and Ms. Miller seconded. Ms. Mitchell noted the confusion about appointments; some are jobs, and some are committees. This role is technically an appointment, but functionally, it is a job. No formal term was set, but the start date would be July 1. Roll Call Vote: Ms. Miller – Aye, Mr. Manter – Aye, Ms. Mitchell - Nay. The motion passed (2-1). Event Permit/1 Day Beer & Wine: Misty Meadows Summer Benefit 8/3 5-7”30 Ms. Mitchell presented a request for a one-day beer.” (Motion: Manter, second: Miller)
June 11, 2025: Offer the Facilities Manager position to John Murray at Grade 8, Step 2, and
Offer the Facilities Manager position to John Murray at Grade 8, Step 2, and
Voted: Yes
Yes: Miller, MitchellNo: Manter
“Mr. Manter made a motion to offer the Facilities Manager position to John Murray at Grade 8, Step 2, and Ms. Miller seconded. Roll Call Vote: Ms. Miller – Aye, Ms. Mitchell – Aye, Mr. Manter – Nay. The motion passed (2-1). Public Comment None.” (Motion: Manter, second: Miller)
May 28, 2025: Move into the Executive Session, and
Move into the Executive Session, and
Voted: Yes
Yes: Miller, MitchellNo: Manter
“Ms. Mitchell made a motion to move into the Executive Session, and Ms. Miller seconded. Roll Call Vote: Ms. Miller – Aye, Mr. Manter – no, Ms. Mitchell - Aye. The motion passed (2–1). Executive Session: The Board may meet on executive session with Special Labor Counsel to investigate charges of criminal mis.” (Motion: Mitchell, second: Miller)
From the West Tisbury Select Board’s official minutes, posted in the town’s Document Center. We check every vote against the members present and quote the exact wording. MassVoter never grades or scores officials. Jessica Miller: from The Martha’s Vineyard Times (April 2026 candidates forum, photo by Eunki Seonwoo). No photo found yet for Skipper Manter or Cynthia Mitchell; they show initials. Skipper Manter (courtesy West Tisbury Police, 2018 promotion photo) and Cynthia Mitchell (April 2022), The Martha’s Vineyard Times.
How to read these pagesWhere the votes come from, how we check them against the official minutes, what isn't included yet, and how to report a mistake.About city pages →