← Carver Select Board

Carver Select Board · 2021–2022 Board · Regular meeting

December 21, 2021

7 recorded votes, 4 with disagreement.

Sources: Official minutes (PDF)

A monthly email on what it voted on, starting in November.

Election Day · Tuesday, Nov 3

Your Carver ballot: 13 quizzes, about a minute each.

Start my ballot →

Attendance

Present: Mark Townsend, Sarah Hewins, Jen Bogart, Jim Hoffman, Robert Belbin

Absent: None

During the meeting:

  • Robert Belbin arrived late (6:39pm).
  • Mark Townsend recused from one or more items (see the notes on the votes).

Every vote, in order

Committee representative

Extend an appointment to Kevin Tracey to the screening committee

Minutes, page 4

AppointFailed · 2–3

Extend an appointment to Kevin Tracey to the screening committee. Hewins stated the item listed for discussion is to include consideration of the Finance Committee representative. Townsend stated the agenda item is to finalize the TASC, including consideration of the Finance Committee representative. Bogart stated it is sketchy & she does not see why the Board would not appoint Tracey upon his acceptance of the request and based on the discussion at the last Select Board meeting. Townsend stated he does not think it is sketchy that it was spoken about at the last Select Board meeting he stated there was not a full Board and he wanted the full Board present to make the decision and that this item would be on the agenda at the next meeting. Hewins stated it is extremely important to have a member of the Finance Committee on the TASC due to the important role the Finance Committee has with the Town Administrator and the Finance Committee has voted for their representative. Belbin stated that he does not feel that Mr. Germain is the best option and the Finance Committee does not have all of the information that the Select Board has and cannot see him as a representative

Yes: Belbin, BogartNo: Hewins, Hoffman, Townsend

From the minutes

“Motion by Bogart to extend an appointment to Kevin Tracey to the screening committee, second by Belbin. Hewins stated the item listed for discussion is to include consideration of the Finance Committee representative. Townsend stated the agenda item is to finalize the TASC, including consideration of the Finance Committee representative. Bogart stated it is sketchy & she does not see why the Board would not appoint Tracey upon his acceptance of the request and based on the discussion at the last Select Board meeting. Townsend stated he does not think it is sketchy that it was spoken about at the last Select Board meeting he stated there was not a full Board and he wanted the full Board present to make the decision and that this item would be on the agenda at the next meeting. Hewins stated it is extremely important to have a member of the Finance Committee on the TASC due to the important role the Finance Committee has with the Town Administrator and the Finance Committee has voted for their representative. Belbin stated that he does not feel that Mr. Germain is the best option and the Finance Committee does not have all of the information that the Select Board has and cannot see him as a representative. Vote 2-3 (Townsend, Hewins, Hoffman).” (Motion: Bogart, second: Belbin)

Read it in the official minutes, page 4 (PDF)

Appoint Germain, the Chair of Finance Committee, to be the Finance Committee representative to the Screening Committee

Minutes, page 5

AppointPassed · 3–2

Appoint Germain, the Chair of Finance Committee, to be the Finance Committee representative to the Screening Committee. Bogart stated that based on the professionalism she has seen at public meetings and based on conversation in Executive Session, she stated she does not feel that it is appropriate. Townsend stated at the 11/2/21 meeting the make-up of the committee was voted on by the Select Board and that would have been the time to change the make-up of the committee. Hoffman stated he would like to clear up a few comments from the 12/7/21 Select Board meeting. It was stated by Mr. Germain that if the Finance Committee choice wasn't approved by the Select Board, then the Finance Committee would not be represented. Hoffman stated that both Pat Meagher and Walter Cole are also on the TASC although they are not on the TASC as the Finance Committee representatives, they are still members of the Finance Committee and the Finance Committee will be represented. In addition, he stated that Germain stated at that same meeting that the charge of the TASC was to have a representative of the School Committee, Planning Board and Finance Committee to be chosen by their respective committees and the Select Board did not have the choice for these appointments. Hoffman stated that was correct, but that was for the previous TASC voted on May 18. On November 2, the Select Board discussed and voted on whether to vote on the representatives of the Planning Board, School Committee and Finance C

Yes: Hewins, Hoffman, TownsendNo: Belbin, Bogart

From the minutes

“Motion to appoint Germain, the Chair of Finance Committee, to be the Finance Committee representative to the Screening Committee by Hewins, second by Townsend. Bogart stated that based on the professionalism she has seen at public meetings and based on conversation in Executive Session, she stated she does not feel that it is appropriate. Townsend stated at the 11/2/21 meeting the make-up of the committee was voted on by the Select Board and that would have been the time to change the make-up of the committee. Hoffman stated he would like to clear up a few comments from the 12/7/21 Select Board meeting. It was stated by Mr. Germain that if the Finance Committee choice wasn't approved by the Select Board, then the Finance Committee would not be represented. Hoffman stated that both Pat Meagher and Walter Cole are also on the TASC although they are not on the TASC as the Finance Committee representatives, they are still members of the Finance Committee and the Finance Committee will be represented. In addition, he stated that Germain stated at that same meeting that the charge of the TASC was to have a representative of the School Committee, Planning Board and Finance Committee to be chosen by their respective committees and the Select Board did not have the choice for these appointments. Hoffman stated that was correct, but that was for the previous TASC voted on May 18. On November 2, the Select Board discussed and voted on whether to vote on the representatives of the Planning Board, School Committee and Finance Committee and that was a change from the first TASC and the vote was unanimous. After much thought, Hoffman stated that agendas, making things personal, respect and moving on- Hoffman referenced emails sent to the Finance Committee from Select Board member Belbin. The reaction to some of the emails personally attacked members of the Select Board because people didn't agree with the way he voted and he takes offense to these. He noted that because he listens to people, does not mean he agrees with everyone he talks to. He would like people to respect decisions made. He respects the Finance Committee choice and it does not mean that he agrees with it. He requests that private agendas and personal attacks stop. Vote 3-2 (Bogart, Belbin).” (Motion: Hewins, second: Townsend)

Read it in the official minutes, page 5 (PDF)

Not exercise the first right of refusal

Minutes, page 6

ApprovePassed · 3–2

Not exercise the first right of refusal. Belbin stated that he would like to talk to the developer. Hewins stated she will have a discussion with the chair of the Planning Board and the Zoning Enforcement Officer to make sure the lots are compliant. Belbin stated that these should be looked at for affordable housing. Hoffman asked for clarification on the option to purchase the land. Hewins stated you would need to have the money, discussions would need to be had with Community Preservation Committee. Belbin stated, as he has before, that he would like these to come before the Board prior to going to permitting boards. LaFond stated this process cannot be changed due to the time frames when applications are submitted. Hewins stated once a Form A is submitted to the Planning Board, the clock starts ticking

Yes: Hewins, Hoffman, TownsendNo: Belbin, Bogart

From the minutes

“Motion by Hewins to not exercise the first right of refusal, second by Hoffman. Belbin stated that he would like to talk to the developer. Hewins stated she will have a discussion with the chair of the Planning Board and the Zoning Enforcement Officer to make sure the lots are compliant. Belbin stated that these should be looked at for affordable housing. Hoffman asked for clarification on the option to purchase the land. Hewins stated you would need to have the money, discussions would need to be had with Community Preservation Committee. Belbin stated, as he has before, that he would like these to come before the Board prior to going to permitting boards. LaFond stated this process cannot be changed due to the time frames when applications are submitted. Hewins stated once a Form A is submitted to the Planning Board, the clock starts ticking. Vote 3-2 (Bogart, Belbin).” (Motion: Hewins, second: Hoffman)

Read it in the official minutes, page 6 (PDF)

Request for One Day Special License

Approve: Request for One Day Special License

Minutes, page 7

ApprovePassed · 3–1

Approve. Belbin stated that Town buildings are not the place for alcohol. If it was not on town property he would not have a problem with it

Yes: Bogart, Hewins, HoffmanNo: BelbinMark Townsend recused and did not take part in this vote.

From the minutes

“Motion to approve by Hoffman, second by Bogart. Belbin stated that Town buildings are not the place for alcohol. If it was not on town property he would not have a problem with it. Vote 3-1 (Belbin).” (Motion: Hoffman, second: Bogart)

Read it in the official minutes, page 7 (PDF)

Select Board notes

Adjourn into Executive Session at 7:40pm

Minutes, page 7

ProceduralPassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Adjourn into Executive Session at 7:40pm

From the minutes

“Motion to adjourn into Executive Session by Belbin at 7:40pm, second by Bogart Roll Call: Affirmative - Bogart, Belbin, Townsend, Hewins, Hoffman.” (Motion: Belbin, second: Bogart)

Read it in the official minutes, page 7 (PDF)

Ratify the Interim Town Administrator Contract of Robert Fennessy

Minutes, page 7

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Ratify the Interim Town Administrator Contract of Robert Fennessy

From the minutes

“Motion to ratify the Interim Town Administrator Contract of Robert Fennessy by Belbin, second by Hewins. Roll call- affirmative: Bogart, Belbin, Townsend, Hewins, Hoffman..” (Motion: Belbin, second: Hewins)

Read it in the official minutes, page 7 (PDF)

Walter Cole

Adjourn at 8:22pm

Minutes, page 8

ProceduralPassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Adjourn at 8:22pm

From the minutes

“Motion to adjourn at 8:22pm by Hewins, second by Belbin. Vote 5-0.” (Motion: Hewins, second: Belbin)

Read it in the official minutes, page 8 (PDF)

From the Carver Select Board’s official minutes, posted in the town’s Agenda Center (2025 on) and its Document Center archive (earlier years). We check every vote against the Select Board members present and quote the exact wording. MassVoter never grades or scores officials. Photos of current members: Mark Townsend and Sarah Hewins from Wareham Week (January 2026); Jim Elliman from Area 58 video of the October 6, 2026 Select Board meeting (identified by the nameplate in front of each member). Members without a photo show initials.

How to read these pagesWhere the votes come from, how we check them against the official minutes, what isn't included yet, and how to report a mistake.About city pages →
Get an email when new quizzes open

MassVoter.com · nonpartisan match quiz · About · How the Legislature voted · Local Votes · Privacy · Support MassVoter

Report an error on this page

See something wrong? A wrong vote, name, date or number? Tell us and we’ll check it against the source and fix it. Fixes are listed on our corrections page.