MassVoter.com← Tisbury Select BoardTisbury Select Board · 2025–2026 Board · Regular meeting
19 recorded votes, 0 with disagreement.
Sources: Official minutes (PDF)
A monthly email on what it voted on, starting in November.
Present: Roy Cutrer, Christina Colarusso, John Cahill
Absent: None
January 6, 2025 — approve all the minutes
Approve all the minutes
“Colarusso made a motion to approve all the minutes Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. APPOINTMENT All Island School Committee Regionalization Sub-Committee- Roy .” (Motion: Colarusso, second: Cutrer)
Appoint Roy Cutrer to the All-Island School Committee Regionalization Sub- Committee
Appoint Roy Cutrer to the All-Island School Committee Regionalization Sub- Committee
Yes: Cahill, Colarusso
“Cutrer Colarusso made a motion to appoint Roy Cutrer to the All-Island School Committee Regionalization Sub- Committee Roll Call Vote. The vote was 2 in favor, 0 opposed, and 1 abstained. Cutrer abstained. DISCUSSION AND POTENTIAL VOTES Reorganization of the .” (Motion: Colarusso, second: Cahill)
Reorganize the board as Colarusso
Reorganize the board as Colarusso
“Board Cutrer made a motion to reorganize the board as Colarusso Chair, Cutrer Vice-chair, Cahill Clerk Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. Colarusso addressed the public by focusing on future goals values to stride towards. Finance Director Search The Select Board discusses the need to replace the retiring Finance Director, Jon Snyder, by the end of the year. They pla.” (Motion: Cutrer, second: Cahill)
Approve the transfer in the amount of 16,860
Approve the transfer in the amount of 16,860
“Cahill made a motion to approve the transfer in the amount of 16,860 Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. Martha's Vineyard Museum- Jaws 50th Anniversary Plans Cathy Mayone from the Museum stated that they have developed a plan for temporary signage and use of parking lots. They are requesting the use of the Municipal lot on June 22 as.” (Motion: Cahill, second: Cutrer)
Approve the museum's plans as presented with the understanding that the museum will find out if the signage can be placed on the poles
Approve the museum's plans as presented with the understanding that the museum will find out if the signage can be placed on the poles
“Cahill made a motion to approve the museum's plans as presented with the understanding that the museum will find out if the signage can be placed on the poles Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. Page 1 of 4 Docusign Envelope ID: 7A7DA6B9-5BF8-4790-AFC4-8A42529F9993 First Friday 2025 Proposal Since the last meeting the Cultural District has met with the Open Space Committee, and they have provided a letter of support w.” (Motion: Cahill, second: Cutrer)
Approve the First Friday Events as presented for July 4, August 1, September 5, October 3 including the closure of Beach Street Extension and the closure of Owen Park
Approve the First Friday Events as presented for July 4, August 1, September 5, October 3 including the closure of Beach Street Extension and the closure of Owen Park
“Cutrer made a motion to approve the First Friday Events as presented for July 4, August 1, September 5, October 3 including the closure of Beach Street Extension and the closure of Owen Park Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. Makers Pasta Shop & Café Alcohol Management Agreement A draft management agreement was presented to the Board between 369 State Road LLC, Little House Café and the Maker Pasta Shop. The purpose of this agreement is so that they can.” (Motion: Cutrer, second: Cahill)
Approve the amended Host Community Agreement
Approve the amended Host Community Agreement
“Cahill made a motion to approve the amended Host Community Agreement Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. Martha's Vineyard Commission-MVP 2.0 Grant Project Elizabeth Durkee from the Martha's Vineyard Commission presents information about the MVP 2.0 grant project, which aims to guide towns through climate resilience planning. The proj.” (Motion: Cahill, second: Cutrer)
Appoint Nancy Gilfoy to join the Regional High School Building Committee
Appoint Nancy Gilfoy to join the Regional High School Building Committee
“Cahill made a motion to appoint Nancy Gilfoy to join the Regional High School Building Committee Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. .” (Motion: Cahill, second: Cutrer)
Authorize Joeseph LaCivita to start conversations with other Towns regarding cost sharing formula
Authorize Joeseph LaCivita to start conversations with other Towns regarding cost sharing formula
“Cutrer made a motion to authorize Joeseph LaCivita to start conversations with other Towns regarding cost sharing formula Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. PUBLIC HEARING 4:45PM- Public Hearing to review and consider a request by NSTAR Electric Company D/B/A Eversource Energy to install 43' of 1-3” conduit and one Handhole HH17/H5 to provide new electric service to 98 William Street C.” (Motion: Cutrer, second: Cahill)
Approve the installation of 43' of 1-3” conduit and one Handhole HH17/H5 to provide new electric service to 98 William Street
Approve the installation of 43' of 1-3” conduit and one Handhole HH17/H5 to provide new electric service to 98 William Street
“Cahill made a motion to approve the installation of 43' of 1-3” conduit and one Handhole HH17/H5 to provide new electric service to 98 William Street Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. TOWN ADMINISTARTOR REPORT 51 Lagoon Pond Road Update Joseph LaCivita stated that Mr. Dubard has secured the door and is going to put a fence around. Dubard has met with Mr. LaCivita and are trying to resolve all the issues so there.” (Motion: Cahill, second: Cutrer)
The proprietor of Lagoon Pond LLC follow steps regarding 51 Lagoon Pond Road by June 24, 2025 to submit or secure all necessary permits to advance the project , receive approval for wastewater flow and resolve the setback issues to complete the project
The proprietor of Lagoon Pond LLC follow steps regarding 51 Lagoon Pond Road by June 24, 2025 to submit or secure all necessary permits to advance the project , receive approval for wastewater flow and resolve the setback issues to complete the project
“Cahill made a motion that the proprietor of Lagoon Pond LLC follow steps regarding 51 Lagoon Pond Road by June 24, 2025 to submit or secure all necessary permits to advance the project , receive approval for wastewater flow and resolve the setback issues to complete the project Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. IT Assessment Update Department Heads had a meeting with IT consultant. At the meeting the results of the assessment were presented, which showed the low satisfaction with the current IT systems. We are looking at advancing systems.” (Motion: Cahill, second: Cutrer)
Approve service for 14 Church Street for additional 75 gallons subject to approval by all related Boards
Approve service for 14 Church Street for additional 75 gallons subject to approval by all related Boards
“Cutrer made a motion to approve service for 14 Church Street for additional 75 gallons subject to approval by all related Boards Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. 39 Lagoon Pond Road Alberice explained that this application is for additional gallons because there will be an Accessory Dwelling Unit built on the property. Currently no building permit has been submitted. No action taken 61 Beac.” (Motion: Cutrer, second: Cahill)
Withdraw the approval for 61 Beach Road
Withdraw the approval for 61 Beach Road
“Cahill made a motion to withdraw the approval for 61 Beach Road Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. Lodging House License Renewals Charles and Charles MV, 85 Summer Street Page 3 of 4 Docusign Envelope ID: 7A7DA6B9-5BF8-4790-AFC4-8A42529F9993 Mansion House, 9 Main .” (Motion: Cahill, second: Cutrer)
Approve the lodging house licenses
Approve the lodging house licenses
“Street Cahill made a motion to approve the lodging house licenses Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. Common Victualler License Renewals Garde East, 52 Beach .” (Motion: Cahill, second: Cutrer)
Approve the common victualler licenses conditioned upon receiving sign offs from Building and Fire department
Approve the common victualler licenses conditioned upon receiving sign offs from Building and Fire department
“Road Cahill made a motion to approve the common victualler licenses conditioned upon receiving sign offs from Building and Fire department Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. Auto Rental License Renewal Atlanta Island Auto Rentals Inc, 4 Water .” (Motion: Cahill, second: Cutrer)
Approve the auto rental licenses
Approve the auto rental licenses
“Street Cahill made a motion to approve the auto rental licenses Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. One-Day Alcohol License Martha's Vineyard Museum, 151 Lagoon Pond Road-Jaws 50th Anniversary- 6.22.25 .” (Motion: Cahill, second: Cutrer)
Approve the one day alcohol licenses
Approve the one day alcohol licenses
“Cahill made a motion to approve the one day alcohol licenses Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. Taxi License Renewals Martha's Vineyard Taxi Admiral Taxi Island Sharks .” (Motion: Cahill, second: Cutrer)
Admiral Taxi — approve the Taxi renewals
Approve the Taxi renewals
“Taxi Cahill made a motion to approve the Taxi renewals Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. MEETING ADJOURNMENT .” (Motion: Cahill, second: Cutrer)
MEETING ADJOURNMENT — adjourn the meeting
Adjourn the meeting
“Cutrer made a motion to adjourn the meeting Roll Call Vote. The vote was 3 in favor, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained. The meeting was adjourned at 6:35PM. Meeting Minutes Recorded by Executive Assistant Elena De Foe, October 7, 2025 Meeting Minutes Approved _______________________ ______________ _______________ _______________ Christina Colar.” (Motion: Cutrer, second: Colarusso)
From the Tisbury Select Board’s official minutes, posted in the town’s Agenda Center. We check every vote against the members present and quote the exact wording. MassVoter never grades or scores officials. Photos: The Martha’s Vineyard Times: Roy Cutrer and James Rogers (2021); John Cahill (2020, from the meeting video); Christina Colarusso (courtesy of Ms. Colarusso, 2026).
How to read these pagesWhere the votes come from, how we check them against the official minutes, what isn't included yet, and how to report a mistake.About city pages →