← Brookline Select Board

Brookline Select Board · 2024–2025 Board · Regular meeting

April 29, 2025

27 recorded votes, 5 with disagreement.

Sources: Official minutes (PDF) · Agenda

A monthly email on what it voted on, starting in November.

Election Day · Tuesday, Nov 3

Your Brookline ballot: 13 quizzes, about a minute each.

Start my ballot →

Attendance

Present: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman

Absent: None

Every vote, in order

Approve miscellaneous items, licenses, and contracts. 3a

Minutes, page 1

ProceduralPassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Approval of miscellaneous items, licenses, and contracts. 3a. Question of approving the following meeting minutes: April 8, 2025 April 15, 2025

From the minutes

“Approval of miscellaneous items, licenses, and contracts. 3a. Question of approving the following meeting minutes: April 8, 2025 April 15, 2025 Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 1 (PDF)

Proclamation of the Brookline Select Board of May 11-18, 2025 as Taiwanese American Heritage Week

Minutes, page 1

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Proclamation of the Brookline Select Board of May 11-18, 2025 as Taiwanese American Heritage Week. Chair Greene read the proclamation.

From the minutes

“3b. Proclamation of the Brookline Select Board of May 11-18, 2025 as Taiwanese American Heritage Week. Chair Greene read the proclamation. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 1 (PDF)

Approve an Authorization to Hire request from the Public Safety Department: Admin

Minutes, page 1

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Question of approving an Authorization to Hire request from the Public Safety Department: Admin. Assistant (C8).

From the minutes

“3c. Question of approving an Authorization to Hire request from the Public Safety Department: Admin. Assistant (C8). Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 1 (PDF)

Approve an appropriation transfer request from the Fire Chief in the amount of $20,000: From: $13,000 Leased Computer Equipment (22002010 5A0017) To: $7,000 Public Safety Equipment (22002020...

Minutes, page 2

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Question of approving an appropriation transfer request from the Fire Chief in the amount of $20,000: From: $13,000 Leased Computer Equipment (22002010 5A0017) To: $7,000 Public Safety Equipment (22002020 5A0003) $20,000 Natural Gas (22002010 561011)

From the minutes

“3d. Question of approving an appropriation transfer request from the Fire Chief in the amount of $20,000: From: $13,000 Leased Computer Equipment (22002010 5A0017) To: $7,000 Public Safety Equipment (22002020 5A0003) $20,000 Natural Gas (22002010 561011) Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 2 (PDF)

Approval for an appropriation transfer request from the Fire Chief in the amount of $10,000: From: $10,000 Uniforms & Protective Clothing (539035) To: $5,000 Professional & Technical Services...

Minutes, page 2

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Approval for an appropriation transfer request from the Fire Chief in the amount of $10,000: From: $10,000 Uniforms & Protective Clothing (539035) To: $5,000 Professional & Technical Services (524010) $5,000 Public Safety R&M (522040)

From the minutes

“3e. Approval for an appropriation transfer request from the Fire Chief in the amount of $10,000: From: $10,000 Uniforms & Protective Clothing (539035) To: $5,000 Professional & Technical Services (524010) $5,000 Public Safety R&M (522040) Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 2 (PDF)

Approve an appropriation transfer request from the Director of Public Buildings in the amount of $150,000: From: $70,000 Public buildings Salaries (510101) $80,000 School buildings Salaries...

Minutes, page 2

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Question of approving an appropriation transfer request from the Director of Public Buildings in the amount of $150,000: From: $70,000 Public buildings Salaries (510101) $80,000 School buildings Salaries (522400) To: $70,000 Public buildings Repairs and Maintenance (522400) $80,000 School buildings Repair and Maintenance (522400)

From the minutes

“3f. Question of approving an appropriation transfer request from the Director of Public Buildings in the amount of $150,000: From: $70,000 Public buildings Salaries (510101) $80,000 School buildings Salaries (522400) To: $70,000 Public buildings Repairs and Maintenance (522400) $80,000 School buildings Repair and Maintenance (522400) Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 2 (PDF)

Approve PW/25-13 with All States Construction for the installation of Bonded Wearing Course at Beacon Street, Craftsland Road, Arlington Road, and Sumner Road in the amount of $2,341,622.90

Minutes, page 2

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Question of approving PW/25-13 with All States Construction for the installation of Bonded Wearing Course at Beacon Street, Craftsland Road, Arlington Road, and Sumner Road in the amount of $2,341,622.90.

From the minutes

“3g. Question of approving PW/25-13 with All States Construction for the installation of Bonded Wearing Course at Beacon Street, Craftsland Road, Arlington Road, and Sumner Road in the amount of $2,341,622.90. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 2 (PDF)

Approve PW/25-12 with Apex Companies, LLC for the FY25 Transportation and Mobility Professional Engineering Services in the amount of $250,600

Minutes, page 3

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Question of approving PW/25-12 with Apex Companies, LLC for the FY25 Transportation and Mobility Professional Engineering Services in the amount of $250,600.

From the minutes

“3h. Question of approving PW/25-12 with Apex Companies, LLC for the FY25 Transportation and Mobility Professional Engineering Services in the amount of $250,600. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 3 (PDF)

Approve contract PW/25-26 "I&I Investigation and Sewer System Rehabilitation Design in Subareas NI-6 East" with BETA Group, Inc. of Norwood, MA in the amount of $244,959 for sewer and pipeline work

Minutes, page 3

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Question of approving contract PW/25-26 "I&I Investigation and Sewer System Rehabilitation Design in Subareas NI-6 East" with BETA Group, Inc. of Norwood, MA in the amount of $244,959 for sewer and pipeline work.

From the minutes

“3i. Question of approving contract PW/25-26 "I&I Investigation and Sewer System Rehabilitation Design in Subareas NI-6 East" with BETA Group, Inc. of Norwood, MA in the amount of $244,959 for sewer and pipeline work. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 3 (PDF)

Approve contract PW/25-34 "Chestnut Hill Commercial Area Transportation Study" with Kittelson and Associates in the amount of $132,469 for phases 1 and 2 of the study

Minutes, page 3

ApprovePassed · 4–1

Question of approving contract PW/25-34 "Chestnut Hill Commercial Area Transportation Study" with Kittelson and Associates in the amount of $132,469 for phases 1 and 2 of the study. John VanScoyoc read a statement: I wish to seek consensus on a modification of our procedures regarding consultant contracts. The immediate concern is the Kittelson contract under item 3j, but the broader concerns are these: 1. for all consultant contracts funded from operational budgets, I believe we should seek an assessment by the requesting department as to whether the consultant contract connects clearly to an operational need, and further that the operational need can be met only by an outside consultant.

Yes: Greene, Pearlman, Sandman, WarrenNo: VanScoyoc

From the minutes

“3j. Question of approving contract PW/25-34 "Chestnut Hill Commercial Area Transportation Study" with Kittelson and Associates in the amount of $132,469 for phases 1 and 2 of the study. John VanScoyoc read a statement: I wish to seek consensus on a modification of our procedures regarding consultant contracts. The immediate concern is the Kittelson contract under item 3j, but the broader concerns are these: 1. for all consultant contracts funded from operational budgets, I believe we should seek an assessment by the requesting department as to whether the consultant contract connects clearly to an operational need, and further that the operational need can be met only by an outside consultant..”

Read it in the official minutes, page 3 (PDF)

Approve a one-day temporary liquor license for Danielle Bertolini d/b/a Brookline Center for Community Mental Health for April 30, 2025, from 7:00 PM - 9:00 PM for a Hand in Hand Community...

Minutes, page 4

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Question of approving a one-day temporary liquor license for Danielle Bertolini d/b/a Brookline Center for Community Mental Health for April 30, 2025, from 7:00 PM - 9:00 PM for a Hand in Hand Community Engagement Event.

From the minutes

“3k. Question of approving a one-day temporary liquor license for Danielle Bertolini d/b/a Brookline Center for Community Mental Health for April 30, 2025, from 7:00 PM - 9:00 PM for a Hand in Hand Community Engagement Event. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 4 (PDF)

Approve a one-day entertainment license for Bartaco Brookline LLC d/b/a bartaco on May 5, 2025, from 11:00 AM -11:00 PM at 1634 Beacon St. for live music with a disc jockey, contingent upon Police...

Minutes, page 4

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Question of approving a one-day entertainment license for Bartaco Brookline LLC d/b/a bartaco on May 5, 2025, from 11:00 AM -11:00 PM at 1634 Beacon St. for live music with a disc jockey, contingent upon Police Department approval.

From the minutes

“3l. Question of approving a one-day entertainment license for Bartaco Brookline LLC d/b/a bartaco on May 5, 2025, from 11:00 AM -11:00 PM at 1634 Beacon St. for live music with a disc jockey, contingent upon Police Department approval. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 4 (PDF)

Approve the renewal seasonal application for All-Alcoholic Beverages License for Game henge Golf LLC Inc d/b/a Hemlock Grill at 1281 West Roxbury Parkway with the proposed manager, Chris Yorty

Minutes, page 4

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Question of approving the renewal seasonal application for All-Alcoholic Beverages License for Game henge Golf LLC Inc d/b/a Hemlock Grill at 1281 West Roxbury Parkway with the proposed manager, Chris Yorty.

From the minutes

“3m. Question of approving the renewal seasonal application for All-Alcoholic Beverages License for Game henge Golf LLC Inc d/b/a Hemlock Grill at 1281 West Roxbury Parkway with the proposed manager, Chris Yorty. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 4 (PDF)

Approve the application of a transfer for an Inn Holder License from Arcadian for Sonder Hospitality USA Inc. to CCLLH, LLC d/b/a Arcadian Hotel at 1200 Beacon Street

Minutes, page 4

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Question of approving the application of a transfer for an Inn Holder License from Arcadian for Sonder Hospitality USA Inc. to CCLLH, LLC d/b/a Arcadian Hotel at 1200 Beacon Street. Question of approving the application for the transfer of an All-Alcohol Beverage License from Arcadian for Sonder Hospitality USA, Inc. to CCLLH, LLC d/b/a Arcadian Hotel at 1200 Beacon Street. Proposed manager is Mohamed Hashesh. Proposed Operating Hours will be Monday-Sunday 11:00am-1:00am.

From the minutes

“3n. Question of approving the application of a transfer for an Inn Holder License from Arcadian for Sonder Hospitality USA Inc. to CCLLH, LLC d/b/a Arcadian Hotel at 1200 Beacon Street. Question of approving the application for the transfer of an All-Alcohol Beverage License from Arcadian for Sonder Hospitality USA, Inc. to CCLLH, LLC d/b/a Arcadian Hotel at 1200 Beacon Street. Proposed manager is Mohamed Hashesh. Proposed Operating Hours will be Monday-Sunday 11:00am-1:00am. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 4 (PDF)

Approve the application for a transfer Common Victualler License from Sonder Hospitality USA, Inc. to CCLLH, LLC d/b/a Arcadian Hotel at 1200 Beacon Street

Minutes, page 5

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Question of approving the application for a transfer Common Victualler License from Sonder Hospitality USA, Inc. to CCLLH, LLC d/b/a Arcadian Hotel at 1200 Beacon Street. Proposed Operating Hours will be Monday- Sunday, 6:30am - 1:00am. Seating will consist of 102 seats.

From the minutes

“Question of approving the application for a transfer Common Victualler License from Sonder Hospitality USA, Inc. to CCLLH, LLC d/b/a Arcadian Hotel at 1200 Beacon Street. Proposed Operating Hours will be Monday- Sunday, 6:30am - 1:00am. Seating will consist of 102 seats. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 5 (PDF)

Approve the application of an Entertainment License, which will consist of radio, taped music, and television Monday-Sunday 11:00am-1:00am

Minutes, page 5

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Question of approving the application of an Entertainment License, which will consist of radio, taped music, and television Monday-Sunday 11:00am-1:00am. Question of approving the application for change of Alternate Manager, Demetrius Simon, to CCLLH, LLC d/b/a Arcadian Hotel at 1200 Beacon Street.

From the minutes

“Question of approving the application of an Entertainment License, which will consist of radio, taped music, and television Monday-Sunday 11:00am-1:00am. Question of approving the application for change of Alternate Manager, Demetrius Simon, to CCLLH, LLC d/b/a Arcadian Hotel at 1200 Beacon Street. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 5 (PDF)

Calendar Review and potential vote on Calendar Items

Minutes, page 5

AppointPassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Calendar Review and potential vote on Calendar Items. Boards and Commissions - Interviews Interviews with various candidates for Boards and Commissions: Brookline Housing Authority (SB-Appointed Seat) Karen Rojas has a bachelor's in economics and has been doing some work with Brookline Housing Authority and is familiar with their back-end processes. She has attended some meetings and finds them informative. Karen noted that there is a lot of miscommunications; some say nothing is being done at the properties, but she sees their work and noted that things take time to process, like grants and other funding sources etc. She is familiar with their rules and regulations. She would apply her social media skills and outreach strategies to connect with the residents.

From the minutes

“Calendar Review and potential vote on Calendar Items. Boards and Commissions - Interviews Interviews with various candidates for Boards and Commissions: Brookline Housing Authority (SB-Appointed Seat) Karen Rojas has a bachelor's in economics and has been doing some work with Brookline Housing Authority and is familiar with their back-end processes. She has attended some meetings and finds them informative. Karen noted that there is a lot of miscommunications; some say nothing is being done at the properties, but she sees their work and noted that things take time to process, like grants and other funding sources etc. She is familiar with their rules and regulations. She would apply her social media skills and outreach strategies to connect with the residents. Conservation Commission Priya Gandbhir is an attorney for the Conservation Law Foundation, leading their Clean Power team. She also served as a Conservation Commissioner for Framingham and currently serves on the Board of Directors of the Massachusetts Association of Conservation Commissions. Ms. Gandbhir is familiar with municipal conservation polices. She would like to help protect open space and create and protect wildlife corridors and opportunities for passive recreation. Brookline Commission on Disability Elizabeth Stryer is visibly impaired and has been able to navigate around town easily. She is an active pedestrian is partially sighted. She is a stroller user and navigates through busy commercial areas. Ms. Stryer noted a challenge she faced during the Boston Marathon where barricades became obstacles to navigate around. She also noted that recycle bins tend to block sidewalks. When asked about audible crosswalk signals, she indicated that she does rely on them sometimes, and finds them helpful. Declarations of Emergency Policy Discussion and possible vote on a policy regarding the delegation of authority to issue Declarations of Emergency. John Sullivan, Fire Chief and Emergency Management Director noted that Town Counsel has been working on this document that finalizes the emergency management plan. This will outline the process in an event of an emergency and the delegation process. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 5 (PDF)

No action on Article 20

Minutes, page 6

ApprovePassed · 4–1

On motion it was, Voted No action on Article 20

Yes: Greene, Sandman, VanScoyoc, WarrenNo: Pearlman

From the minutes

“On motion it was, Voted No action on Article 20 Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc Against: David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 6 (PDF)

Favorable Action on article 17 as revised by the AC subcommittee

Minutes, page 7

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

On motion it was, Voted Favorable Action on article 17 as revised by the AC subcommittee.

From the minutes

“On motion it was, Voted Favorable Action on article 17 as revised by the AC subcommittee. Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 7 (PDF)

Favorable Action on Article as revised Warrant Article 9 - Annual (FY26) Budget Appropriations Article (Advisory Committee)

Minutes, page 7

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

On motion it was, Voted 5-0 Favorable Action on Article as revised Warrant Article 9 - Annual (FY26) Budget Appropriations Article (Advisory Committee).

From the minutes

“On motion it was, Voted 5-0 Favorable Action on Article as revised Warrant Article 9 - Annual (FY26) Budget Appropriations Article (Advisory Committee)..”

Read it in the official minutes, page 7 (PDF)

Refer articles 14 to the Select Board

Minutes, page 10

ApprovePassed · 4–1

On motion it was, Voted to refer articles 14 to the Select Board

Yes: Greene, Sandman, VanScoyoc, WarrenNo: Pearlman

From the minutes

“On motion it was, Voted to refer articles 14 to the Select Board Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc Against: David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 10 (PDF)

Refer articles 15 to the Select Board

Minutes, page 11

ApprovePassed · 4–1

On motion it was, Voted to refer articles 15 to the Select Board

Yes: Greene, Sandman, VanScoyoc, WarrenNo: Pearlman

From the minutes

“On motion it was, Voted to refer articles 15 to the Select Board Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc Against: David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 11 (PDF)

Favorable Action on Chair Greene revised language: Be it resolved that Brookline town meeting expresses its support for H. 1014/ S.588 An act establishing a climate change super fund to build...

Minutes, page 11

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Voted 5-0 Favorable Action on Chair Greene revised language: Be it resolved that Brookline town meeting expresses its support for H. 1014/ S.588 An act establishing a climate change super fund to build polluter accountability and fund climate resilience. ADDED: provided, however, that the Brookline town meeting does not support. Section 2 t. Of said new chapter 21 p. Of the general laws relating to the requirement that structural iron and steel used in any public work contract be produced or made in whole or substantial part in the United States, from the initial melting stage through the application of coatings. For the reason that said subsection is not germane to the bill, and would place significant financial and other burdens on such public projects in Brookline.

From the minutes

“Voted 5-0 Favorable Action on Chair Greene revised language: Be it resolved that Brookline town meeting expresses its support for H. 1014/ S.588 An act establishing a climate change super fund to build polluter accountability and fund climate resilience. ADDED: provided, however, that the Brookline town meeting does not support. Section 2 t. Of said new chapter 21 p. Of the general laws relating to the requirement that structural iron and steel used in any public work contract be produced or made in whole or substantial part in the United States, from the initial melting stage through the application of coatings. For the reason that said subsection is not germane to the bill, and would place significant financial and other burdens on such public projects in Brookline. Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 11 (PDF)

Favorable Action

Minutes, page 12

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

Voted 5-0 Favorable Action.

From the minutes

“Voted 5-0 Favorable Action. Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 12 (PDF)

Favorable Action on Article 28 as amended by the Advisory Committee

Minutes, page 12

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

On motion it was, Voted 5-0 Favorable Action on Article 28 as amended by the Advisory Committee.

From the minutes

“On motion it was, Voted 5-0 Favorable Action on Article 28 as amended by the Advisory Committee. Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 12 (PDF)

Favorable Action on Article 29 as amended

Minutes, page 13

ApprovePassed · Unanimous, 5 present

On motion, it was, Voted 5-0 Favorable Action on Article 29 as amended

From the minutes

“On motion, it was, Voted 5-0 Favorable Action on Article 29 as amended Aye: Bernard Greene, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, John VanScoyoc, David Pearlman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 13 (PDF)

Favorable Action on Article

Minutes, page 13

ApprovePassed · 3–1

On motion it was, Voted 3-1-1 Favorable Action on Article

Yes: Greene, Pearlman, WarrenNo: VanScoyocAbstained: Sandman

From the minutes

“On motion it was, Voted 3-1-1 Favorable Action on Article Aye: Bernard Greene, Paul Warren, David Pearlman Against: John VanScoyoc Abstained: Michael Sandman.”

Read it in the official minutes, page 13 (PDF)

From the Brookline Select Board’s official minutes, posted on the town’s CivicClerk meetings portal. We check every vote against the Select Board members present and quote the exact wording. MassVoter never grades or scores officials. Photos: Brookline.News (candidate profiles, 2024 and 2026) and the Michael Rubenstein for Brookline Select Board campaign website.

How to read these pagesWhere the votes come from, how we check them against the official minutes, what isn't included yet, and how to report a mistake.About city pages →
Get an email when new quizzes open

MassVoter.com · nonpartisan match quiz · About · How the Legislature voted · Local Votes · Privacy · Support MassVoter

Report an error on this page

See something wrong? A wrong vote, name, date or number? Tell us and we’ll check it against the source and fix it. Fixes are listed on our corrections page.