MassVoter.com← Brookline Select BoardBrookline Select Board · 2024–2025 Board · Regular meeting
32 recorded votes, 3 with disagreement.
Sources: Official minutes (PDF) · Agenda
A monthly email on what it voted on, starting in November.
Your Brookline ballot: 13 quizzes, about a minute each.
Start my ballot →Present: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Michael Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman
Absent: None
Enter into executive session
On motion it was, Voted to enter into executive session
“On motion it was, Voted to enter into executive session Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approve miscellaneous items, licenses, and contracts. a
Approval of miscellaneous items, licenses, and contracts. a. Approval of Meeting Minutes from June 25, 2024.
“Approval of miscellaneous items, licenses, and contracts. a. Approval of Meeting Minutes from June 25, 2024. Approved as amended Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approve a Boards and Commissions Email Record Retention Policy
Question of approving a Boards and Commissions Email Record Retention Policy. In Select July 9, 2024
“b. Question of approving a Boards and Commissions Email Record Retention Policy. In Select July 9, 2024 Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approval for a Special Permit request from the Boston Marathon Jimmy Fund Walk to take place on October 6, 2024, along Beacon Street
Approval for a Special Permit request from the Boston Marathon Jimmy Fund Walk to take place on October 6, 2024, along Beacon Street.
“c. Approval for a Special Permit request from the Boston Marathon Jimmy Fund Walk to take place on October 6, 2024, along Beacon Street. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approve the following two (2) Authorization to Hire Requests from the Finance Director: Deputy Treasurer (T11) Finance Assistant (C8)
Question of approving the following two (2) Authorization to Hire Requests from the Finance Director: Deputy Treasurer (T11) Finance Assistant (C8)
“d. Question of approving the following two (2) Authorization to Hire Requests from the Finance Director: Deputy Treasurer (T11) Finance Assistant (C8) Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Annual report submitted by the Indigenous People Celebration Committee
Annual report submitted by the Indigenous People Celebration Committee.
“e. Annual report submitted by the Indigenous People Celebration Committee. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Annual report submitted by the Brookline Emergency Preparedness Committee
Annual report submitted by the Brookline Emergency Preparedness Committee.
“f. Annual report submitted by the Brookline Emergency Preparedness Committee. Town Administrator Carey announced that this item is a requirement of the state, it is a policy indicating what is stored and where in town related to hazardous waste materials. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approve contract PW/24-22 "Parking Lot Improvements" with A&D Services in the amount of $77,518.55 for improvements to the parking lot at 124 Fisher Ave
Approval of contract PW/24-22 "Parking Lot Improvements" with A&D Services in the amount of $77,518.55 for improvements to the parking lot at 124 Fisher Ave.
“g. Approval of contract PW/24-22 "Parking Lot Improvements" with A&D Services in the amount of $77,518.55 for improvements to the parking lot at 124 Fisher Ave. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approve contract PW/25-01 "Disposing of Leaves and Related Work" with Mayer Tree Service, Inc. in the amount of $260,840.00 for the removal and disposing of yard waste and other related work
Approval of contract PW/25-01 "Disposing of Leaves and Related Work" with Mayer Tree Service, Inc. in the amount of $260,840.00 for the removal and disposing of yard waste and other related work.
“h. Approval of contract PW/25-01 "Disposing of Leaves and Related Work" with Mayer Tree Service, Inc. in the amount of $260,840.00 for the removal and disposing of yard waste and other related work. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Accept a gift from the Simon family in the amount of $7,913.16 to the Fire Department
Acceptance of a gift from the Simon family in the amount of $7,913.16 to the Fire Department.
“i. Acceptance of a gift from the Simon family in the amount of $7,913.16 to the Fire Department. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approve PW/21-10 with Preferred Contractors, Inc. for FY25 Temporary Seasonal Refrigeration at Jack Kirrane Ice Rink in the amount of $123,037.25
Question of approving PW/21-10 with Preferred Contractors, Inc. for FY25 Temporary Seasonal Refrigeration at Jack Kirrane Ice Rink in the amount of $123,037.25.
“j. Question of approving PW/21-10 with Preferred Contractors, Inc. for FY25 Temporary Seasonal Refrigeration at Jack Kirrane Ice Rink in the amount of $123,037.25. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approve PW/23-02 with Argus Construction Corp. for FY25 Repairs and Installation of Chain Link Fencing in the amount of $104,390.00
Question of approving PW/23-02 with Argus Construction Corp. for FY25 Repairs and Installation of Chain Link Fencing in the amount of $104,390.00.
“k. Question of approving PW/23-02 with Argus Construction Corp. for FY25 Repairs and Installation of Chain Link Fencing in the amount of $104,390.00. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approve PW/24-01 with Park Landscape Associates, Inc. for FY25 Beacon Street and General Grounds Maintenance in the amount of $264.375.00
Question of approving PW/24-01 with Park Landscape Associates, Inc. for FY25 Beacon Street and General Grounds Maintenance in the amount of $264.375.00.
“l. Question of approving PW/24-01 with Park Landscape Associates, Inc. for FY25 Beacon Street and General Grounds Maintenance in the amount of $264.375.00. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approve PW/24-02 with Perez Landscaping for FY25 Skyline Park Maintenance in the amount of $47,370.00
Question of approving PW/24-02 with Perez Landscaping for FY25 Skyline Park Maintenance in the amount of $47,370.00.
“m. Question of approving PW/24-02 with Perez Landscaping for FY25 Skyline Park Maintenance in the amount of $47,370.00. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approve PW/23-01 with M. Neves, Inc. for FY25 General Maintenance of School Grounds in the amount of $112,240.40
Question of approving PW/23-01 with M. Neves, Inc. for FY25 General Maintenance of School Grounds in the amount of $112,240.40.
“n. Question of approving PW/23-01 with M. Neves, Inc. for FY25 General Maintenance of School Grounds in the amount of $112,240.40. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approve PW/23-03 with North-Eastern Tree Service, Inc. for FY25 Upkeep of Trees and Related Work in the amount of $407,020.00
Question of approving PW/23-03 with North-Eastern Tree Service, Inc. for FY25 Upkeep of Trees and Related Work in the amount of $407,020.00.
“o. Question of approving PW/23-03 with North-Eastern Tree Service, Inc. for FY25 Upkeep of Trees and Related Work in the amount of $407,020.00. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approve PW/23-04 with K5 Corporation for FY25 Pavement Markings in the amount of $133,445.00
Question of approving PW/23-04 with K5 Corporation for FY25 Pavement Markings in the amount of $133,445.00.
“p. Question of approving PW/23-04 with K5 Corporation for FY25 Pavement Markings in the amount of $133,445.00. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approve PW/24-03 with Dagle Electrical Contractors, Inc. for FY25 Traffic Signals and Emergency Streetlight Services in the amount of $48,680.00
Question of approving PW/24-03 with Dagle Electrical Contractors, Inc. for FY25 Traffic Signals and Emergency Streetlight Services in the amount of $48,680.00.
“q. Question of approving PW/24-03 with Dagle Electrical Contractors, Inc. for FY25 Traffic Signals and Emergency Streetlight Services in the amount of $48,680.00. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approve PW/15-01 with Casella Waste Management of Massachusetts, Inc. for FY25 Disposal of Solid Waste in the amount of $1,040,000.00
Question of approving PW/15-01 with Casella Waste Management of Massachusetts, Inc. for FY25 Disposal of Solid Waste in the amount of $1,040,000.00.
Yes: Greene, Pearlman, Sandman, WarrenAbstained: VanScoyoc
“Question of approving PW/15-01 with Casella Waste Management of Massachusetts, Inc. for FY25 Disposal of Solid Waste in the amount of $1,040,000.00. Board member VanScoyoc would like to hear about the future of recycling, feeling at some point there In Select July 9, 2024 may be a transition to another method. He asked whether these contracts were reviewed by the Solid Waste Advisory Committee prior to this approval. Commissioner Chute reviewed that these renewals are annual contracts for disposal and collection. This is the fifth year of a five-year extension of contractual rates negotiated 5 years ago. She reviewed that the contractor, Casella Waste, has been providing a strong recycling component and is looking at some new innovative recycling measures. Commissioner Chute reviewed the waste and recycling tonnage and said that the DPW is looking at other options for the future. Chair Greene offered a future agenda item to review possible changes in the solid waste and recycling programs. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman Abstained: John VanScoyoc.”
Approve PW/16-01 with Casella Waste Management of Massachusetts, Inc. for FY25 Curbside Collection, Hauling, and Processing of Single Stream Recycling in the amount of $2,113,733.00
Question of approving PW/16-01 with Casella Waste Management of Massachusetts, Inc. for FY25 Curbside Collection, Hauling, and Processing of Single Stream Recycling in the amount of $2,113,733.00.
Yes: Greene, Pearlman, Sandman, WarrenAbstained: VanScoyoc
“Question of approving PW/16-01 with Casella Waste Management of Massachusetts, Inc. for FY25 Curbside Collection, Hauling, and Processing of Single Stream Recycling in the amount of $2,113,733.00. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman Abstained: John VanScoyoc.”
Ground Floor Commercial Incentive Standards Vote
Ground Floor Commercial Incentive Standards Vote
“Ground Floor Commercial Incentive Standards Vote Discussion and possible vote on the Ground Floor Commercial Incentive Standards. Maria Morelli, Senior Planner, reviewed this is the final draft of the standard guidelines related to the development of ground floor commercial space. Board member Warren and others offered some revisions to the document. This is an innovative mechanism and they appreciate the input. Chair Greene added that this mechanism will support middle income and workforce renters by offering various rental rates. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
POSTPONED - Project Eligibility Letter Application for 429 Harvard Street 40B Continued discussion regarding a Select Board comment letter for the Project Eligibility Letter for 429 Harvard Street
POSTPONED - Project Eligibility Letter Application for 429 Harvard Street 40B Continued discussion regarding a Select Board comment letter for the Project Eligibility Letter for 429 Harvard Street.
“POSTPONED - Project Eligibility Letter Application for 429 Harvard Street 40B Continued discussion regarding a Select Board comment letter for the Project Eligibility Letter for 429 Harvard Street. It was noted that the developer withdrew the application at this time. Police General Orders Policies Chief Paster will review and request a vote on changes to the Police Department's General Orders to reflect the Massachusetts Police Accreditation Commission (MPAC) updated set of standards: GO 2.2 Absenteeism Sick Injured GO In Select July 9, 2024 5.2 Criminal Investigations GO 10.2 Responding to Individuals with Mental Health Conditions GO 14.1 Juvenile Operations GO 21.1 Communications GO 30.3 Use of Force GO 32.1 Victim-Witness Assistance GO 35.2 Motor Vehicle Pursuits Chief Paster added this is a new set of policies to get them into compliance with a new set of standards related to the accreditation process. Some of them are general updates due to changes in the process and technological advances. Some language changes reflect their own updates and processes. Chair Greene recommended reading these policies, particularly those dealing with mental health conditions and enforcement. The Board noted the importance of the force to be up-to-date on these changing policies. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
The Police Commissioners Advisory Committee, in collaboration with Chief Paster and the Police Department, will review and request a vote to revise Brookline Police Department General Order 24.1...
The Police Commissioners Advisory Committee, in collaboration with Chief Paster and the Police Department, will review and request a vote to revise Brookline Police Department General Order 24.1 Investigatory Stop and Frisk and Threshold Inquiry. Scott Ananian, member of the Police Commissioners Advisory Committee, viewed this as the next step in the committee's work. He flagged some significant changes in two areas of case law related to motor vehicle investigatory stops and changes to the report writing section.
“The Police Commissioners Advisory Committee, in collaboration with Chief Paster and the Police Department, will review and request a vote to revise Brookline Police Department General Order 24.1 Investigatory Stop and Frisk and Threshold Inquiry. Scott Ananian, member of the Police Commissioners Advisory Committee, viewed this as the next step in the committee's work. He flagged some significant changes in two areas of case law related to motor vehicle investigatory stops and changes to the report writing section. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approve and submitting to the Advisory Committee, a Reserve Fund Transfer request in the amount of $493,953 from the School Department
Question of approving and submitting to the Advisory Committee, a Reserve Fund Transfer request in the amount of $493,953 from the School Department. School Administrators, Susan Givens, Deputy Superintendent for Finance, and Diane Johnson, Director of Finance, provided a PowerPoint on their reserve fund transfer request. They explained the original shortfall of over $1 million and the efforts taken to reduce that to the requested $493,953. Some of the driving factors were, changes in special revenue funds, special education expenses, transportation and depleted one-time revenues.
“Question of approving and submitting to the Advisory Committee, a Reserve Fund Transfer request in the amount of $493,953 from the School Department. School Administrators, Susan Givens, Deputy Superintendent for Finance, and Diane Johnson, Director of Finance, provided a PowerPoint on their reserve fund transfer request. They explained the original shortfall of over $1 million and the efforts taken to reduce that to the requested $493,953. Some of the driving factors were, changes in special revenue funds, special education expenses, transportation and depleted one-time revenues. They provided the budgetary process going forward that included tighter position controls, purchase order management and contract approval and oversight. There was also a discussion about using circuit breaker funds if the reserve fund was not available, acknowledging that it is not the best practice. The board asked if it would be possible to reduce the request further if they had additional time to review the books. In Select July 9, 2024 Approved to submit the request to the Advisory Committee Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Reappoint the following candidates to Boards and Commissions: Chair Greene made the introduction to the reappointments
Vote to reappoint the following candidates to Boards and Commissions: Chair Greene made the introduction to the reappointments. Board member Warren noted that an incumbent with a term up results in an open seat. The incumbent can reapply and so can others; however-it seems like there is some reluctance to apply against a long-term incumbent. He encouraged a diverse applicant pool for the towns' numerous boards and commissions. Building Commission Janet Fierman Nathan Peck
“Vote to reappoint the following candidates to Boards and Commissions: Chair Greene made the introduction to the reappointments. Board member Warren noted that an incumbent with a term up results in an open seat. The incumbent can reapply and so can others; however-it seems like there is some reluctance to apply against a long-term incumbent. He encouraged a diverse applicant pool for the towns' numerous boards and commissions. Building Commission Janet Fierman Nathan Peck Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Age-Friendly Cities Committee Carol Caro John Seay
Age-Friendly Cities Committee Carol Caro John Seay
“Age-Friendly Cities Committee Carol Caro John Seay Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Transportation Board Nancy Moore Len Wholey Wendy Friedman Brian Kane
Transportation Board Nancy Moore Len Wholey Wendy Friedman Brian Kane
“Transportation Board Nancy Moore Len Wholey Wendy Friedman Brian Kane Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Preservation Commission Richard Panciera
Preservation Commission Richard Panciera
“Preservation Commission Richard Panciera Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Appoint seven members to the Fisher Hill West Uses Advisory Committee: Bernard Greene Carlos Ridruejo In Select July 9, 2024 Caryl Goodman Marilyn Tressel Steve Heikin Steve Sousa Michael Roper
Question of appointing seven members to the Fisher Hill West Uses Advisory Committee: Bernard Greene Carlos Ridruejo In Select July 9, 2024 Caryl Goodman Marilyn Tressel Steve Heikin Steve Sousa Michael Roper
“Question of appointing seven members to the Fisher Hill West Uses Advisory Committee: Bernard Greene Carlos Ridruejo In Select July 9, 2024 Caryl Goodman Marilyn Tressel Steve Heikin Steve Sousa Michael Roper Chair Greene reviewed the proposed membership. The Fisher Hill West Uses Advisory Committee (the Committee) will make land use and potential disposition recommendations to the Select Board regarding the Town-owned Fisher Hill Avenue parcels at 110, 124, 150 Fisher Avenue and 146 Hyslop Road; formerly referred to as the Newbury College West Campus (the Fisher Hill West Site). This will be a public committee following a public process. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Approve and authorizing the Town Administrator to sign an agreement between the Town and Brookline Interactive Group regarding support for use of public, educational, and government channels,...
Question of approving and authorizing the Town Administrator to sign an agreement between the Town and Brookline Interactive Group regarding support for use of public, educational, and government channels, facilities, programming and services. Brookline Interactive Group's Executive Director, Jessica Smyser, spoke on the Memorandum of Understanding. The MOU outlines the work that they do with an appendix on how they support Brookline's hybrid meetings. She reviewed how they are mainly supported by the fees from the large cable companies and the challenges with their cable subscribers decreasing. She spoke briefly about that renegotiating process. The challenge and task are finding alternative sources of revenue which they are working on. That includes seeking grants and expanding on revenue-generating programs.
“Question of approving and authorizing the Town Administrator to sign an agreement between the Town and Brookline Interactive Group regarding support for use of public, educational, and government channels, facilities, programming and services. Brookline Interactive Group's Executive Director, Jessica Smyser, spoke on the Memorandum of Understanding. The MOU outlines the work that they do with an appendix on how they support Brookline's hybrid meetings. She reviewed how they are mainly supported by the fees from the large cable companies and the challenges with their cable subscribers decreasing. She spoke briefly about that renegotiating process. The challenge and task are finding alternative sources of revenue which they are working on. That includes seeking grants and expanding on revenue-generating programs. Approved Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
Set the date for the 2024 Special Town Meeting to be held November 19, 2024
Question of setting the date for the 2024 Special Town Meeting to be held November 19, 2024.
The minutes say the board voted but do not give a count or say how each member voted.
“Question of setting the date for the 2024 Special Town Meeting to be held November 19, 2024. Deputy Town Administrator Melissa Goff reviewed the Fall Special Town Meeting schedule. The Warrant opens August 8, 2024, and closes September 5, 2024. Fall 2024 Special Town Meeting begins on November 19, 2024 November 19 Tuesday November 20 Wednesday November 21 Thursday December 3 Tuesday (if necessary) December 4 Wednesday (if necessary) Approved.”
Set the date for the 2024 Special Town Meeting to be held November 19, 2024.: In Select July 9, 2024
Question of setting the date for the 2024 Special Town Meeting to be held November 19, 2024.: In Select July 9, 2024
“In Select July 9, 2024 Aye: Bernard Greene, John VanScoyoc, Mike Sandman, Paul Warren, David Pearlman.”
From the Brookline Select Board’s official minutes, posted on the town’s CivicClerk meetings portal. We check every vote against the Select Board members present and quote the exact wording. MassVoter never grades or scores officials. Photos: Brookline.News (candidate profiles, 2024 and 2026) and the Michael Rubenstein for Brookline Select Board campaign website.
How to read these pagesWhere the votes come from, how we check them against the official minutes, what isn't included yet, and how to report a mistake.About city pages →